Matters of Belonging

Matters of Belonging brings to the foreground critical practices within ethnographic museums in relation to their diverse stakeholders, with a special focus on collaboration with artists and differently constituted, self-identified communities. This book emerges from the EU-funded project SWICH (Sharing a World of Inclusion, Creativity and Heritage) that places ethnographic museums at the centre of ongoing debates about Europe¿s shifting polity and questions around heritage, citizenship and belonging. Addressing diverse political climates and citizenship regimes, legal frameworks and colonial/migratory histories, the articles seek to question the role of ethnographic and world cultures museums within contemporary negotiations of how to define Europe, Europeans, and European heritage, especially mindful of the region¿s colonial and migratory pasts.

The book is neither celebratory nor congratulatory, and does not depict a triumphal overcoming by ethnographic museums of their troubled pasts. Its aim is to think critically about these museums¿ responses, to identify both pitfalls and positive developments, and to sketch out possible futures for museums generally, and ethnographic museums specifically, as they try to locate themselves within discussions about Europe and its futures.

Central to the book¿s argument is that it may exactly be in their entanglement with the colonial past that these museums can become important sites for thinking about colonial entailments in the present. Facing up to this past is the beginning of addressing these larger legacies. The authors suggest that the ethnographic museum has been the site not just for trenchant questioning of colonial durabilities in contemporary Europe, but also for the development of new practices ¿ of collaboration and authority-sharing, of recognition and belonging. This book explores these models, not as complete, but as starting points to push forward new practices.

Contents

Acknowledgements

List of images

Introduction

Wayne Modest

Heritage

The Museum Inside-out ¿ Twenty Observations

Nicholas Thomas

Museums and Source Communities: Reflections and implications

Laura Peers

Collaboration and the Dilemma of the Exotic: A Research Note

Barbara Plankensteiner

Our House is Made of Thin, Burning Ice. Let¿s Dance

Sandra Ferracuti

Creativity

Questions of Belonging

Alana Jelinek

Love and Loss in the Ethnographic Museum

Rajkamal Kahlon

Eyes in the Back of Your Head

Bianca Baldi

I came as a Stranger

Aleksandra Pawloff

The Long Walk: Following the Tick Ticking Sounds into the Unknown ¿ Or the Omitted

Jacqueline Hoàng Nguy¿n

Inclusion

Shared Authority Matters: Collaboration with Heritage Bearers with Migrant Background

Tina Palai¿ and Bojana Rogelj ¿kafar

Uncomfortable Memory and Community Participation at the Barcelona Ethnological and World Cultures Museum

Salvador García Arnillas and Lluís-Josep Ramoneda Aigüadé

The Making of a Point of View: A Participatory Exhibition at the Pigorini Museum in Rome

Rosa Anna Di Lella ¿ Loretta Paderni

Out of Boxes: Touching Wor(l)ds, Moving Pictures

Urban Nomad Mixes

For Contingent Collaboration: The Making of the Afterlives of Slavery exhibition at the Tropenmuseum

Rita Ouédraogo, Robin Lelijveld, Martin Berger, Richard Kofi, and Wayne Modest